Grenadine Face-off

Grenadine is one of the most common and versatile sweeteners and flavorings in classic mixology; it’s also damn difficult to find — the real stuff, anyway. Originally a pomegranate-based syrup, grenadine has been hybridized and bastardized out of existence, so that virtually all commercial versions contain little if any actual pomegranate juice. This is a pity — pomegranate has such a bright, fruity (for lack of a better word) flavor that to replace it with a mishmash of high-fructose corn syrup and red food coloring is a real insult to honest cocktails.

Fortunately, it’s pretty easy to make your own grenadine at home. I’ve come across several recipes for the do-it-yourselfer, and there are two that seem to be the most popular: a cold-process mix of pomegranate juice and sugar, and a hot-process method that involves a pomegranate reduction and sugar. But which version makes the more promising grenadine?

Last week I cozied up in my kitchen with a couple of bottles of POM pomegranate juice and a bag of sugar, and set out to determine which process makes the better grenadine.

VERSION ONE — COLD-PROCESS

I started the comparison with a cold-process version. I first came across this recipe in David Wondrich’s Killer Cocktails a little more than a year ago, and it’s been my go-to recipe ever since.

Take one cup of pomegranate juice, and place it in a jar with one cup of granulated sugar. Seal tightly and shake like hell until all of the sugar is dissolved. Add another ounce or two of sugar and repeat. Voila – a simple grenadine. [Optional: Add an ounce of high-proof vodka or grain alcohol as a preservative. You can also store this in a plastic container in the freezer; the high volume of sugar keeps it from freezing, and you can just tip out a little frigid syrup each time you need it.]

The cold process produces a grenadine that has all the bright, fresh flavor of pomegranate juice, with enough sugar to make it useful as a sweetener in cocktails such as a Jack Rose or a Bacardi cocktail. When working with drink recipes, you may need to use more of the homemade version than the recipe calls for to create the desired sweetness. This version also lacks the depth of color found in commercial varieites; if you like, add a few drops of red food coloring.

VERSION TWO – HOT PROCESS

I first came across this version on Jared Brown & Anistatia Miller’s Martini Place; a recent exchange over at Boston Cocktails got me thinking about it again, and this experiment marks the first time I’ve tried using the hot process for grenadine.

Pour two cups of POM into a saucepan. Bring to a boil, then simmer over medium-low heat until reduced by half. Add one cup of sugar, and stir until dissolved. Remove from heat and let cool; if desired, add high-proof vodka or grain alcohol as a preservative (it also keeps well, and doesn’t freeze solid, in a plastic container in the freezer).

This process produces a grenadine that has a deeper color and a richer flavor. While the cold process makes a grenadine that is fresh and light, the hot process makes a more intensely flavored end product, with a distinct “cooked” taste. It’s still not as sweet as the commercial versions, so you may need to alter the proportions in your cocktail recipes, but the rich, red color is there.

VERDICT: Hard to say — both versions are far superior to any commercial grenadine I’ve tried, and comparing the two is more a challenge for personal tastes. I find myself drawn to the fresher flavor of the cold-process grenadine, as when it’s used in a cocktail such as a Jack Rose or El Presidente, that brightness helps lift the overall flavor of the drink. (The cold process is faster and easier, too.) But the hot process is not without merit, and I can see how its deeper, more intense flavor could be useful in multiple-ingredient drinks such as a Planter’s Punch, to help the pomegranate’s flavor stand a better chance among the other ingredients.

Not to be anticlimactic about it, but both versions are worth trying. The flavor of each is different — fresher, fruitier — from the commercial version, so be prepared for the difference (you can also add a few drops of almond extract, or an ounce of orgeat, to your grenadine, for a not unpleasant variation that hews a bit closer to the flavor of the commercial brands).

72 Responses to Grenadine Face-off

  1. [...] Modern Cocktail No. 21 oz Dalmore 151 1/2 oz Sloe gin1 dash Orange bitters1 dash Absinthe1 dash house-made grenadine (don’t buy the crappy sugary Rose’s brand when it’s so easy to make your own) [...]

  2. Sonia Martinez-Romaih says:

    Ok, I am at wits end looking for Routin 1883 Orgeat Syrup and Grenadine and have found people saying that they found it at a “coffee wholesaler” in Minneapolis. One question, (pretty please) WHICH COFFEE WHOLESALER? All the ones I have looked at don’t have it. Please let me know.

  3. [...] color.  Yuck.  So I went on a quick quest to find grenadine recipes.  There are two processes:  cold process and a process akin to making simple syrup.  I ended up using the simple syrup process, which is [...]

  4. [...] quite different results even before you consider adding vermouth, so I prepared a batch of both homemade grenadine and raspberry syrup and settled in to decide what my ultimate version of the Clover Club [...]

  5. W. Wren says:

    In Minneapolis, you can buy Routin syrups at Surdyk’s liquor store. I picked up a bottle of the orgeat yesterday.

  6. Rodney says:

    Thanks for the recipe! I was tired of buying that Rose’s crap, knowing all it was was HFC and food dye, what a ripoff! Langers makes a 100% pomegranite juice that I found at my local supermarket. I have made both of your recipes and so far tried the cold one, waiting for the heated one to cool to try it. Thanks again!

  7. [...] it bears mentioning because it’s called for in so many cocktails. A few great recipes exist online for making your own. Steer away from commercial brands that don’t contain a drop of [...]

  8. [...] Modern Cocktail No. 2 1 oz Dalmore 15 1 1/2 oz Sloe gin 1 dash Orange bitters 1 dash Absinthe 1 dash house-made grenadine (don’t buy the crappy sugary Rose’s brand when it’s so easy to make your own) [...]

  9. [...] good gin for best results. You may use in this cocktail homemade grenadine or raspberry syrup for great drink. Be carefully with raw eggs. Actually the quality fresh eggs are [...]

  10. [...] winter suggestions: home-made grenadine; clementine juice with clove [...]

  11. [...] The Cocktail Chronicles favors David Wondrich’s super simple method: put a cup each of sugar and pomegrenate juice in jar and shake till dissolved. Add one or two ounces of sugar, shake again, and you’re done. The Chronicles notes that it’s not as dark red as commercial grenadines, and that you may need to use a bit more than recipes call for. [...]

  12. John Tigue says:

    Did this over the holiday. Actually liked a combo of both together: fresh fruit and deeper notes of the cooked version blended to get all the benefits in one drink.

  13. Lydia says:

    Does anyone know how long the grenadine these recipes are good for?

  14. Brent says:

    I’ve been stewing on this ever since reading this article and the follow-up comments, wanting to make my own grenadine soon.

    I’m wondering if it wouldn’t be possible to make the cooked grenadine taste fresher, minimizing the caramelized/cooked flavors, by reduction boiling it at higher elevations.

    Having mountains close by, couldn’t I take my camp stove up as high as I can get and use that to reduce my pomegranate juice without introducing too many “cooked” flavors? Conceivably I could reduce it at MUCH lower temps by reducing it a higher elevation/lower temp.

    Is this crazy?

  15. [...] case you feel inspired to make your own grenadine, and actually, it isn’t that complicated, The Cocktail Chronicles has a good recipe. [...]

  16. [...] case you feel inspired to make your own grenadine, and actually, it isn’t that complicated, The Cocktail Chronicles has a good recipe. [...]

  17. [...] mixture of the two since I macerated the seeds. I got the instructions from All The Marmalade and The Cocktail Chronicles. The result is this fresh, fruity syrup that’s a rich and satisfying plummy color. Completely [...]

  18. [...] with the POM I was able to make homemade grenadine, which really elevated our Hurricane cocktails to a new level. Or maybe it was the 4 oz. of rum per [...]

  19. [...] to Cocktail Chronicles, I learned that it is easy to make your own [...]

  20. […] grenadine is just pomegranate and sugar.  I found three recipes I wanted to try out.  Two from Cocktail Chronicles and one from Jeffrey […]

  21. […] to Cocktail Chronicles, I learned that it is easy to make your own […]

Leave a reply