This one been done yet?

After a couple of weeks of dipping into the rye and applejack to commemorate the arrival of autumn, tonight I inexplicably had the urge to break out the St. Germain and the Aperol, and start tinkering to see what happens.

Here’s what happened — not too bad, if I say so myself, though I’m still pondering the level of St. Germain; at 1/2 ounce the drink was still in the bracingly tart/bitter range, but at 3/4 ounce, the sweetness is moving in. I may dicker with the proportions some more, either dialing back on the St. Germain or giving the lemon juice an extra little kick, but I’m also anticipating that I’m way behind the times here (wouldn’t be the first time), and that a drink very much like this one has been featured on a cocktail menu since last April.

Give it a try, if you like, and let me know your thoughts.

  • 1 1/2 ounces gin (I used Bombay original)
  • 1/2 ounce fresh lemon juice
  • 1/2 ounce Aperol
  • 1/2 ounce St. Germain

Shake with cracked ice, strain into chilled cocktail glass.

UPDATE: The sweetness was starting to get to me as I wrapped up the post, so I went and mixed up another, using only 1/2 ounce of St. Germain. Contrary to my initial concern, this version is much more balanced than the proportions I initially had, so I’ve changed the recipe to reflect this.

15 Responses to This one been done yet?

  1. Louis says:

    Sounds nice – I have everything but the lemons, so I’ll have to wait until tomorrow to try it.

    I’m thinking that this might be nice with grapefruit juice, too.

  2. stephen says:

    sounds interesting. it might be a good drink for a rye based grapefruit amaro i made a long time ago… it was meant to be a aperol style amaro rather than a dasher bottle cocktail bitter. really similar except drastically less sweet. i made two liters and drank one of them straight. good use of grapefruit rinds i salvaged from the pastry chef.

    rye whiskey
    grapefruit rind
    hibiscus flower (be careful of potency)
    adding pomegrante seeds wouldn’t be horrible either.

    kind of like something that appeared on the gumbo pages quite a while ago but more fun in bigger doses.

  3. Mark Altherr says:

    I tried this last night. Absolutely a perfectly balanced cocktail. The bitterness of the Aperol makes the drink. This is now a house favorite. Interesting that I only had Aperol and St. Germain due to a recent visit to LeNell’s and on their recommendation.

  4. Mike S. says:

    Paul, this is really quite good. But please, you must give it a NAME! How am I supposed to enter it into my massively-annotated copy of Craft of the Cocktail without a name?

  5. AmateurHour says:

    I didn’t have Aperol handy so I substituted Campari and upped the St. Germain to 3/4 oz. to counteract the extra bitterness. It also makes for a great drink that tastes remarkably like pink grapefruit juice (much more so than a Jasmine thanks to the floral notes of the St. Germain). I’ve taken to calling that one a Bitter Elder but I’m looking forward to trying it with the Aperol as well.

  6. gilrain says:

    This is excellent. I used it this evening as my “last chance, Aperol!” ultimatum, after two previous unhappy experiences. Very good! Wonderfully balanced, and a lovely color, too. I might experiment with garnishes — an orange twist, maybe, rather than lemon.

    You really need to name this one, as I’ll be mixing it frequently. I may blog about it, even.

  7. tinylo says:

    Tried the “Bitter Elder”, as described here and it is a spectacular cocktail. Tastes like Texas Ruby Red grapefuit juice right out of the can (a good thing!). Also it’s fairly weak with the Campari, Lemon Juice and St. Germain, allowing one to enjoy two or three cocktails without serious effects.


  8. [...] afternoon, from 4:30 (VIP arrival) to 7:30, I’ll be shaking up a mess of Dunniettes during the Cocktail Hour, which appears to be SOLD OUT. Get ‘em while they [...]

  9. [...] Ein weiteres Rezept, über das ich kürzlich gestolpert bin, ist der Dunniette Cocktail von Paul Clarke [...]

  10. Chris says:

    Yeah, Paul, howzabout a name? I just made this (we finally have both Aperol & St. Germain in Oklahoma), & it is DEE-LICIOUS!


  11. Paul says:

    Finally settled on a name a while back (following a suggestion from Murray Stenson): the Dunniette (as in, “done yet?”)

  12. Paul says:

    The cocktail bar Drink substitutes grapefruit juice for the lemon juice and calls this a Dejuner.

  13. Paul says:

    (PS – Drink is a bar in Boston…)

  14. [...] all sound pretty interesting. Another fellow blogger and respected writer, Paul Clarke even posted one of his own experiments, wondering if his combination had been “done yet”. I tried it and immediately put it on [...]

  15. [...] internet sometimes is that I right now, I can link you to the creation blog post for this cocktail. It’s right here. Created in 2007 by Paul Clarke, some rad dude in Seattle, the drink got its name from the title of [...]

Leave a reply