Bitter Maestro

It’s been a long, busy summer of mostly ignoring this blog, and if left to my own devices I’d likely let the radio silence continue until well after Labor Day. But in response to several inquiries and gentle nudges following the last round of Mixology Monday — a theoretically monthly event that last took place in May — I once again donned my blogging beanie and found a host (or nine) for upcoming events, the first of which is today (at least it’s still today for another half hour or so).

When I put out the call for hosts via Twitter (I’m @cocktailchron, in case you’re wondering), I wasn’t surprised that the first offer came from Lindsey Johnson, who in her day job — if that’s the right term for it — works with the spirits industry as the maven behind Lush Life Productions, and who keeps her social media street cred by not only being a tireless Tweeter (sorry — usually I avoid such new-media lingo, but my amour for alliteration won out) and by participating in social-media focused panel discussions such as the one she joined me on last month at Tales of the Cocktail, but by also publishing the blog, Brown, Bitter and Stirred — which, as luck would have it, is the theme for this month’s MxMo.

While it’s still August, autumn seems to be creeping in early here in the Pacific Northwest, and dark, boozy drinks laced with a little elaborate Italian liqueur are perfectly suited to the next 10 months of mostly unbroken gray. Here’s a drink I was introduced to last fall that I wrote up for the San Francisco Chronicle earlier this year: the Bitter Maestro.

The Bitter Maestro is from Brooke Arthur, who was then at Range and now helms the bar at Prospect in San Francisco. I swung by Range last October on the night before Whiskyfest, to say hi to Brooke and to spend a little time at Range’s small, comfortable bar. With practically no direction from me, Brooke brought over the three things I needed most at 9 o’clock on a Thursday evening: salad, ice cream and a cocktail built on a base of cask-strength whiskey.

Brooke said that the Bitter Maestro was related to a drink from John Deragon at PDT, and while the stump-blaster she poured me had a base of 140-plus-proof Thomas Handy Rye, it also works well with something of a more modest (though still mighty) octane, such as Rittenhouse bonded or Russell’s Reserve Rye. Playing off this spicy base is a small pour of applejack (though Laird’s bonded apple brandy works well, especially if you have a higher-proof rye in the mix), with a little mellowing from Dubonnet rouge and the bitter angle provided by a half-ounce of Amaro Nonino.

In the realm of bitter liqueurs, Nonino is a bit of a pussycat along the lines of Averna, as compared to the rough-trade bitterness found in stuff like Unicum or Fernet Branca, and Nonino’s gentle nip of bitter is a nice counterpoint to the roar of the rye. For a change of pace and to bump up the bitterness a tad, I’ve tried the Maestro with Bonal Gentiane-Quina substituted for the Dubonnet; it dries out the drink a little more (though it doesn’t need it), and gives it a little more back-palate action for those times when the mood takes you there.

Anyway, thanks to Brooke for introducing me to this drink and for sharing the recipe.

Bitter Maestro

  • 1 1/2 ounces rye whiskey (go for higher proof)
  • 1/2 ounce applejack or apple brandy
  • 1/2 ounce Dubonnet rouge
  • 1/2 ounce Amaro Nonino
  • 1 dash pomegranate concentrate or grenadine

Combine in a mixing glass and fill with ice; stir well and strain into chilled cocktail glass. Twist a bit o’ lemon peel over the drink and discard, and garnish with a few pomegranate seeds.

Want to see what everyone else has been up to for Mixology Monday? Head over to Lindsey’s place and check out the submissions.

4 Responses to Bitter Maestro

  1. KeithP says:

    Hi Paul — I was inspired post reading your post above on the Bitter Maestro and made one up last night. It is a really nice drink. For some odd reason I expected (probably took the name a little too serious) it to be a punch in the taste buds, yet, it is a smooth, well balanced drink. As the drink warms the lingering bitterness intensifies on the after palate in very nice way.

    Great recipe/great post.

  2. [...] caught my eye for a recreate and the first of these for me to try was Paul’s entry called the Bitter Maestro. Created by Brooke Arthur while at the Range in San Francisco it is an excellent drink to show case [...]

  3. David says:

    Paul, as a Seattelite I should tell you, they have a few bottles of Root at the re-located U Village licquor store. “We’re the only ones on the west coast,” said the guy at the cash register. Which is wierd since it’s bottled in Monrovia, CA.

    I think it was a kind of perfect storm – or synchronicity – but I had a variety of other special ingredients, and the results might be to your liking:

    Homecoming
    1 1/2 oz Root
    1/2 oz Whipper Snapper
    2 dashes Marie Al Monte

    Stir with ice in a tumbler and enjoy.

    This one can be consumed in larger quanitities but is based on a persnicketty ingredient, a Geniane-Kina aperitif wine that they’re currently stocking at Di Laurentii’s:

    1 1/2 Bonal aperitif wine
    2 dashes Root
    2 dashes Whipper Snapper whiskey
    2 dashes Marteau absinthe

    Thanks for posting!

  4. [...] not so distant kissing cousins.  I first came across the below drink reading, as usual, a post by Paul for a MxMo.  The drink was created by Brooke Arthur of Range in San Fran as a way of highlighting [...]

Leave a reply